Section B – TWO questions ONLY to be attempted John Louse, the recently retired chief executive of Zogs Company, a major listed company, was giving a speech reflecting on his career and some of the aspects of governance he supported and others of which he was critical. In particular, he believed that board committees were mainly ineffective. A lot of the ineffectiveness, he said, was due to the lack of independence of many non-executive directors (NEDs). He believed that it was not enough just to have the required number of non-executive directors; they must also be ‘truly independent’ of the executive board. It was his opinion that it was not enough to have no material financial connection with a company for independence: he believed that in order to be truly independent, NEDs should come from outside the industry and have no previous contact with any of the current executive directors. In relation to risk committees, he said that in his experience, the company’s risk committee had never stopped any risk affecting the company and because of this, he questioned its value. He said that the risk committee was ‘always asking for more information, which was inconvenient’ and had such a ‘gloomy and pessimistic’ approach to its task. He asked, ‘why can’t risk committees just get on with stopping risk, and also stop making inconvenient demands on company management? Do they think middle managers have nothing else to do?’ He viewed all material risks as external risks and so the risk committee should be looking outwards and not inwards. Since retiring from Zogs, Mr Louse had taken up a non-executive directorship of SmallCo, a smaller private company in his town. In a meeting with Alan Ng, the new chief executive of Zogs, Mr Ng said that whilst risk management systems were vital in large companies like Zogs, fewer risk controls were needed in smaller companies like SmallCo. Required: (a) Define ‘independence’ in the context of corporate governance and critically evaluate Mr Louse’s comment that greater independence of non-executive directors is important in increasing the effectiveness of board committees. (8 marks) (b) Describe the roles of a risk committee and criticise Mr Louse’s understanding of the risk committee in Zogs Company. (9 marks) (c) Assess whether risk committees and risk mitigation systems are more important in larger companies, like Zogs, than in smaller companies like SmallCo. (8 marks)